COSY MEETING-OF-MINDS WORKSHOP
CoSy Project:
Meeting of Minds in Action: Natural and Artificial
PARIS 16-18 SEPT 2007
Post-Workshop contributions are available below: Latest first
The Workshop Schedule is here.
Select links below to see presentations and other materials received so far
Speakers whose slides have not yet been received are listed at the end.
- Yuko Munakata (Added 25 Nov 2007)
Title: Developing cognitive flexibility: Learning mechanisms
and representational change
Abstract:
Children show striking developments in cognitive flexibility,
becoming increasingly able to overcome habits to respond
appropriately to the changing environment. What drives these
changes? This talk explores the roles of increasingly active
and abstract representations, and of error-driven and
self-organizing learning mechanisms. We test behavioral
predictions from neural network models regarding effects of
language, practice, and feedback on children's cognitive
flexibility.
(For more information see the publications list.)
- Kevin O'Regan (Added 15 Nov 2007)
Title: CoSy Speaker: How to build phenomenal consciousness into a robot
For more information, please see Kevin's Web page
And
Sensorimotor Approach to Phenomenal Consciousness. (ASSC10 Tutorial)
A simple introduction to the sensorimotor approach to understanding
the quality of sensory experience, with some change blindness
demos and nice pictures.
- Robert Vickerstaff (Added 7 Nov 2007)
Title: Modeling navigation in desert ants and vision in jumping spiders
Abstract:
I will talk about two invertebrate species displaying a surprisingly
rich set of behaviours for their small size, and my attempts to
produce dynamical system models to mimic and explain these
abilities. Path integration in Saharan desert ants allows
surprisingly accurate homing in a largely featureless environment. I
will present a neural network-based model showing a simple way to
reproduce many features of the ant's behaviour. Jumping spiders
of the genus Portia have an unusual visual system giving them very
high visual acuity in a very small field of view. I will introduce
work aimed at understanding how they use their vision as part of
their rich and varied hunting behaviour.
- Henrik Christensen (Added 29 Oct 2007)
Title: Cosy Speaker: Challenges in artificial cognitive systems
Abstract:
Artificial Cognitive Systems is the study of embodied systems that
can perceive, represent, acquire and reason about their own and
others activities in the world to enable goal achievement. The
design of systems that are truly cognitive would be a major
departure from how IT systems are designed, implemented and utilized
today. At the heart of this problem are system organization and
representations that facilitate communication, generalization,
learning, reasoning and fusion. At the same time to be meaningful
these systems must be embedded in the real world and as such
be faced with the richness and diversity of the external
environment. To study such systems there is a need for a
multi-disciplinary approach that allows holistic consideration of
all the aspects across systems theory, AI, perception, statistical
models, language theory and formal methods. In this presentation
a number of general challenges for cognitive systems are outlined
and the approach adopted to these problems in CoSy is also
discussed.
- Kim Plunkett (Added 20 Oct 2007)
Title: Connectionist approaches to language acquisition
Abstract:
How is lexical structure based on the underlying speech and visual
categorisation infants have already acquired during the first year
of life? We use a neural network model to demonstrate that good
categorisation of auditory and visual stimuli in self-organising
maps, leads to extension of a label to other objects within the same
category, even after a single presentation of a word-object pair. We
show that the ability to generalise labels to objects of like kinds,
commonly referred to as the taxonomic assumption, is an emergent
property of the model. Finally, we examine the role of constraints
imposed on the Hebbian associations in the pairing of objects and
labels and show how generalisation can be prevented.
- Neil Berthier (Added 19 Oct 2007)
Title: Development of reaching in infants
Abstract:
The development of human infant reaching will be discussed from a
computational viewpoint. Significant challenges to the infant will
be discussed as well as aspects of the task that allow for infants
to use simple algorithms to learn to reach effectively.
- Cecilia Heyes (Added 18 Oct 2007)
Title: Imitation from sensorimotor learning
Abstract:
Imitation constitutes a special class of reactions to recalled or
incoming stimulation, in which the action responses match or
correspond with the action stimuli. However, even in cases where
the 'correspondence problem' is most acute (e.g. when a system
imitates a facial expression or a whole body movement), imitation
may not require any special types of computation or innate
knowledge. The associative sequence learning (ASL) hypothesis
suggests that the development of imitation (and the mirror system)
depends on task- and species-general processes of associative,
sensorimotor learning. I shall discuss evidence in support of this
view from behavioural and neurophysiological studies of imitation in
adult humans.
- Thomas Collett (Added 16 Oct 2007)
Title: Insect-level intelligence as displayed in arthropod spatial behaviour
Abstract:
I will explore this topic, concentrating on learning and memory,
using examples from the navigational behaviour of social insects and
crabs. Navigational behaviour is particularly informative, because
the animals' rich motor output gives many hints about likely
mechanisms underlying the behaviour.
- Annette Karmiloff-Smith (Added 16 Oct 2007)
Title: Built-in modules vs a developmental process of
gradual modularisation: Insights from genetic disorders
Abstract:
In this talk, I will argue that data from typically developing
infants demonstrate how human brains become progressively
specialised and localised for specific cognitive functions over
developmental time, rather than starting out that way. Moreover,
rather than pointing to genetically specified cognitive-level
modules as some would claim, data from developmental disorders
illustrate how despite proficient behaviour on some tasks, cognitive
and brain processes are atypical involving a lack of progressive
specialisation and localisation of function. In general, I will
stress the importance of building full developmental trajectories of
cognitive functions from the earliest basic-level cross-domain
processes in infancy through childhood to the emergent higher-level
domain-specific cognitive processes in the adult endstate.
- Randall O'Reilly (Added 5 Oct 2007)
Title:
Abstract representations and embodied agents: prefrontal cortex
and basal ganglia contributions
Abstract:
Using biologically-based computational models of the prefrontal
cortex and basal ganglia (together with posterior cortical
areas), my colleagues and I have developed new insights into the
development of abstract, rule-like representations, which are
critical for higher level cognitive functions. We are currently
applying these models to simulated robotic agents equipped with
realistic sensory-motor systems, to understand how cognitive
control might emerge in embodied agents engaged in
developmentally-realistic tasks (e.g., playing with blocks,
sorting by colors, etc). We are also exploring how a wide range
of standard cognitive control/executive function tasks can be
performed in a single system, by building upon more basic
primitive skills that develop in naturalistic environments.
- Laurie Santos (Added 4 Oct 2007)
Title: Primate understanding of objects and motion
Abstract:
My talk will discuss how primates represent other objects and,
in particular, if there is evidence that other primates can
represent unobserved aspects of their physical and social world.
I'll discuss recent work on monkey social cognition and some
new work exploring whether monkeys share a human essentialist
bias.
- Guenther Knoblich (Added 4 Oct 2007)
Title: Two Challenges for Robotics: Mirroring and Joint Action
Abstract:
Recent research on the links between perception, action, and
cognition has led to a new understanding of how people perceive
each other and how they cooperate with one another. In a
nutshell, people use their own action capabilities, emotions,
and sensations to perceive, predict, and understand others and
to perform joint actions with them. Of course, this development
has potentially important implications for robotics because it
opens up a road for constructing robot societies where robots
learn from each other or perform actions together. However, the
recent progress in psychology and the cognitive neurosciences
has also resulted in a renewed focus on intentionality,
experience, and social relations. It is far from clear how these
capabilities could be technically implemented in robots. In my
talk I will provide an overview of important findings and
discuss which aspects of these findings may be realistically
transferable from humans to robots.
- Aaron Sloman (Added 3 Oct 2007)
Title:
Cosy Speaker: Understanding causation in robots, animals and children:
Hume's way and Kant's way.
Abstract:
For Hume, causation was just a matter of correlation, and current
Bayesian theories of causation fit that general idea, adding
conditional probabilities. For Kant, causation implied a kind of
necessity, analogous to the necessity in mathematical reasoning.
There have been disputes as to who was right, whereas I'll argue
that both notions of causation are needed and are used by
intelligent systems. Roughly Humean causation is all you have when
you merely have strong evidence regarding what causes what, whereas
in some cases you know *why* something causes something, e.g. why
going round a house in one direction produces one series of
experiences and going round in the opposite direction produces
another, and why when two centrally pivoted gear wheels made of
rigid impenetrable material are meshed if one turns clockwise
clockwise the other *must* turn counter-clockwise. The history of
science is full of cases where Humean causation is replaced by
Kantian causation as a result of deeper understanding. Kantian
causal understanding, when available, is more powerful, e.g. because
it can be used to deal with novel situations. Currently no robots
that I know of have any Kantian understanding, and this is a very
serious deficiency. Human children acquire Kantian understanding in
a piecemeal and idiosyncratic way. It is not clear whether any other
animals have this ability, but there is prima-facie evidence that
some do. I shall base my presentation on a subset of the topics
presented by Jackie Chappell and myself at a recent workshop on
natural and artificial cognition.
Our slides are available here:
http://www.cs.bham.ac.uk/research/projects/cogaff/talks/wonac/
Added later:
Backround notes on model-based semantics and symbol tethering
-------------------------------------------------------------------
Slides not yet received
(Follow links for more information about the speakers and their researcch).
- Karen E. Adolph
Developing flexibility
Behavioral flexibility is the essence of goal-directed action.
This presentation focuses on three aspects of flexibility:
perceiving changing possibilities for action under variable and
novel conditions, modifying ongoing movements to suit the
current constraints on action, and finding new means to achieve
a desired outcome. Flexibility will be described across the
life-span, from infants to elderly, as participants cope with
various challenges to reaching, balance, and locomotion.
A paper reporting this work is available online:
http://www.psych.nyu.edu/adolph/PDFs/MinnSymp2005.pdf
Learning to Learn in the Development of Action. In
Action As An Organizer of Learning and Development: Volume 33 in
Volume 33 in the Minnesota Symposium on Child Psychology
Series 2005
Edited by John J. Rieser, Jeffrey J. Lockman, Charles A. Nelson
- Luciano Fadiga
From Hand Actions to Language: Anatomo-Physiological Links between
Monkey Mirror Neurons and Human Broca's Area
The classical serial flow-diagram describing how sensory
information is processed and eventually transformed into
movements by the brain has becoming more and more implausible
because of neuroanatomical and neurophysiological evidence. In
the first part of my presentation I will discuss how this
association between stimulus and response, manifesting itself at
single neuron level, might provide the goal to the movements.
Thus, movements are transformed into actions and, perhaps more
interestingly, may give origin to action representations,
playing a crucial role in understanding the other individuals
and the environment around us. In the second part of my
presentation, I will discuss the possible link between action
representation, action understanding and interindividual
communication, in the peculiar framework of human language.
See the papers here:
http://web.unife.it/progetti/neurolab/publications.htm
- Thomas Shipley
Event segmentation and action recognition
My talk will review recent research on how humans decompose and
recognize events. We are beginning to understand some of the
interplay between top-down and bottom-up processes in event
understanding. I will outline a geometric model of low-level
event segmentation, and discuss its potential role in children's
verb learning. I will also discuss perception - action
interactions and the role of motor cortex in action recognition.
Here I will review recent EEG work in which we use the mu rhythm
as indicator of mirror system activity to study action
recognition in infants and learning by imitation in adults.
- Linda Smith
Words and objects from the first person view: A dynamic and embodied
approach to attention
Understanding early word learning requires an understanding of
the real-world physical and social environment in which learning
takes place. However, the relevant aspects of this environment
for the learner are only those that make contact with the
learner's sensory system. I will present new findings (from a
collaborative effort with Chen Yu, Hanako Yoshida, and Alfredo
Pereira) using a novel method that seeks to describe the visual
learning environment from a young child's point of view. The
method consists of a multi-camera sensing environment consisting
of two head-mounted mini cameras that are placed on both the
child's and the parent's foreheads respectively. The main
results is that the adult and child's view are fundamentally
different in that the child's view is more dynamic and centered
on one object at time. These findings have broad implications
for how one thinks about toddler's attentional task as opposed
to adults. In one sense, toddlers have found cheap solution:
Selectively attend not by changing internal weights but by
bringing the attended object close to your eyes so it is the
only one in view.
- Felix Warneken
Acting for and with others: Developmental and comparative
perspectives on prosocial behavior
What are the psychological prerequisites for prosocial behaviors
such as altruistic helping and joint cooperative activities? By
integrating a developmental and comparative perspective, I aim
at elucidating aspects of prosocial behavior which humans share
with their closest primate relatives from aspects which emerge
only in human ontogeny. I will provide evidence that young
children as well as chimpanzees possess the cognitive and
motivational prerequisites for helping: They are able to
understand another individual's unfulfilled goal and have the
altruistic motivation to act on their behalf. With regard to
cooperative activities, experimental evidence suggests that
chimpanzees are not so much different from young children in
their ability to coordinate their actions with another
individual in a cooperative situation, but only human children
appear to form a representation of these actions as part of a
joint plan with a collective goal.
- Jeremy Wyatt
Cosy Speaker: On Architectures for Intelligent Robots:
Distributed Representation & Shared Workspaces
There are several strands of work on architectures for
intelligent agents, from cognitive science, psychology, robotics
and artificial intelligence. Each emphasises a different aspect
of the problem, and offers a differently flavoured solution.
Some emphasise a single, central model of the world, others the
distributed nature of control, or the need for minimal
representation, or hierarchy. I will talk about yet another
architecture suitable for intelligent agents, or more strictly,
an architectural schema. This emphasises the use of specialised
representations, which are distributed across several work
spaces, and refined collaboratively by several processes. This
way of thinking allows us to explore answers to several problems
such as: (what we call) the filtering problem; the binding
problem; and the process management problem. I will support my
argument by describing some case studies in which an
implementation of the schema (CAS - CoSy Architecture Schema) is
used to create specific architectural instantiations.
-------------------------------------------------------------------
Updated: 21 Jan 2009; 25 Nov 2011
Maintained: Aaron Sloman