Special Issue of Journal of
INTEGRATED COMPUTER-AIDED ENGINEERING  (IOS Press)
on
Evolutionary Computing and Neural Networks 
          		

			PAPER REVIEW FORM
============================================================
     
Title:
     
Author(s):

Reviewer:                                Due Date: 5 May 2000

Please complete and return this form by the date indicated above. 
Sections I, II and III are for the guest editor and editor-in-chief only; 
Section IV, which is the essential part of the review, will be sent 
to the author. Your comments will be held in strict confidence. 

Please return your review report by EMAIL to:  x.yao@cs.bham.ac.uk 


                      I. OVERALL EVALUATION

Please justify your overall evaluation in Sections II and IV.

                                Excellent  Good  Fair  Poor
Originality                :
Significance               :
Technical Soundness        :
Presentation               :
Relevance to the           :
special issue

     
    		II. CONFIDENTIAL COMMENTS TO THE EDITOR(S)





     
                 III. OVERALL RECOMMENDATION (DELETE ALL BUT ONE)
     

1.  ACCEPT: The paper should be accepted by the special issue in 
		 its present form.

2.  REVISE AND ACCEPT: The paper is acceptable subject to further 
			    revision as detailed in Section VI.

3.  NEUTRAL: I don't have strong opinion about accept/reject, and will be
                  happy to follow other referees' recommendation.

4.  REJECT:  The paper does not make sufficient contribution to the field
     		  to warrant acceptance. (You must give reasons and comments to
		  justify this.)

     
     
     ___________________________________________________________
     Signature                                      Date
     
     

     
               IV. DETAILED COMMENTS TO THE AUTHOR(S)
               --------------------------------------
Please type or print below your detailed comments to the author(s).
It is important that you indicate WHAT REVISIONS, if any, the author(s) 
should make. List optional and mandatory changes separately. Feel free to
attach extra sheets as needed.